accolades from Saveur, Culture, Good Food Awards, Urban Famr, and Wine Spectator

Mixology Basics: How to make Craft Cocktails using Shrub Syrups

With the popular DIY movement underfoot, it is likely that you may want to try your hand at a few craft cocktails.  This post will help you with some basic ratios and ideas for mixing up craft cocktails using drink syrups (either tangy shrub syrups or their sweeter sister – simple syrups).  There are also links to specific cocktail recipes that use shrub syrups as an ingredient.

What is a Shrub Syrup vs a Simple Syrup

Three varieties of drink syrups to use in mixology of craft cocktails using shrub syrups
Three different Shrub Syrups

Basically a shrub syrup is a fruity-acidic concentrated syrup that can be used to flavor carbonated water, iced tea, lemonades, cocktails or mocktails.  Bartenders (mixologists) are embracing shrub syrups as an innovative alternative to the sour element of citrus in cocktails.

The term “shrub” is derived from the Arabic word sharāb meaning “to drink”.  The American version has its origins in the 17th century, when vinegar was used to preserve berries and other fruits.  The shrub syrup of Colonial times resulted in a sweet and sour syrup that was most often mixed with water and served as a refreshing drink on the porch or in the field.

A common ratio of ingredients in making a shrub syrup would include equal parts of fresh berry juice, apple cider vinegar and pure cane sugar. Of course, variations in the type of fruit, vinegar or sugar are endless, but the classic recipe uses the ingredients listed above in equal parts.  Aromatics or herbs are often added, sometimes in place of the berries and sometimes as an enhancement to the berries.

Simple syrups are sweeter, as they do not include the vinegar. A typical ratio of ingredients in simple syrups is equal parts of juiced fruit to sugar. Aromatics or herbs are infused in the same method and variations as in the shrub syrups.

Making Shrub Syrups: Hot vs. Cold Processing

The process of making shrubs varies.  The quickest and easiest method of making shrubs is the stove top method. The “best” way to make shrub syrups is debated. Here are the most popular methods.

Typical Hot Shrubbing Method:

  1. add equal parts of sugar and water to a pot and heat until the sugar dissolves;
  2. add fruit to the sugar syrup and simmer until fruit breaks down and is blended into the syrup;
  3. strain the syrup, add the vinegar to it, pour into a bottle and store in the refrigerator.

Hot Shrubbing without Making Simple Syrup First:

In our kitchen we do not water the syrup down at all and follow this process instead:

  1. We start by juicing the fruit in a Swedish Mehu Liisa juicer;
  2. simmer the fruit juice and sugar until the sugar dissolves
  3. add herbs and/or aromatics to the pot and let it steep for 20-30 minutes
  4. strain the syrup and add the type and amount of vinegar you prefer (we base this on the type of fruit being used. Sometimes it is apple cider vinegar, sometimes coconut vinegar, sometimes white wine vinegar, etc.
  5. Bring the syrup with the vinegar up to a rolling boil to pasteurize and pour into hot bottles and cap

Cold Processing Method:

Some people prefer a “cold processing” method, and believe that the taste is more intense and more pure. Cold shrubbing is typically done as follows:

  • let the berries steep in sugar for several days until their juices are released;
  • Strain the berry-sugar syrup to remove pulp or solids, add vinegar and pour into a large vessel
  • Let the fruit juice and vinegar sit for 15-30 days and then bottle up.

I vary my method for making shrub syrups depending on the type of fruit or shrub base.  Strawberries are slower to release their juice, and I might opt for cold shrubbing  strawberries.  Some of the woodier herbs used in infusion need quite a bit of heat to release their oils and I would opt for a stove top shrubbing process in this case.

If you are making your own shrub syrups, give yourself some lead time before you plan on using them.  The vinegar is very strong and pungent at the beginning.  It will mellow quite a bit over time as it melds with the fruit and sugar.  After a few weeks you will have a shrub syrup with sweet, tart and fruity flavors in perfect harmony.

Why use Shrub Syrups in Craft Cocktails?

Both the tangy shrub syrups and the sweeter simple syrups have their place in beverages. It is really just a matter of taste.  The shrub syrups can add a depth and complexity that you might not get with a simple syrup and they are, of course, less sweet.  

Many of the cocktails that recommend using shrub syrups will also include bitters.  This tends to round out your drink, giving you the full range of sweet, sour, and bitter flavors.  A few other reasons the shrub syrups have come back in vogue include:

  • many are made with apple cider vinegar, which is considered good for your health (but hard to get down by the spoonful)
  • shrub syrups add complexity and depth and cut the sweetness (see above explanation)
  • they are often considered an alternative to using citrus juices in cocktails, which some people cannot have or do not like
  • cocktails with shrub syrups are said to stimulate the appetite
  • they are shelf stable (unlike citrus), and easy to keep on hand (can store for up to a year in the fridge)
  • vinegar is a good carrier of chile peppers if you like to add spice to your beverages.

Mixology Basics

Craft cocktails using bourbon and tart cherry shrub syrup
Bourbon with Tart Cherry Shrub Syrup

I think mixology is very similar to baking actually.  The core ingredients are always there in fairly specific ratios and then you can get creative with flavor enhancement around this core.

I was a bartender throughout my twenties, as I was working my way in and out of grad school (I did not take a very direct course).  Bartending helped me get familiar with the flavor profiles of the many spirits and liqueurs, but back then fresh fruit was only seen on the garnish tray.  

While the current popularity of mixology has definitely enhanced the creative side of cocktails, it has also brought the status of a “mixologist” up to celebrity chef status, which can be intimidating to those of us who just want to make and share a good drink.

I think perhaps we need to relax with this trend a bit more.   Mixing your own cocktails is basically about learning the approximate ratios between a spirit, a sweetener (syrup), and a complementary liqueur.  Flavored bitters, fresh fruit, smoke,  fresh vegetables or herbs are the enhancements that might take a good cocktail to a great one.  When starting out with DIY mixology, you might find you are plenty happy with “good”.

Ratios of Spirits to Drink Syrups in Making Craft Cocktails

The following blueprint is one easy way to look at mixing drinks in your home with the materials you have at hand.  For a more in-depth look at mixology, I would recommend DIY Cocktails, by Marcia Simmons & Jonas Halpren.

For Martinis or Cocktails that are Strained into chilled glass (aka “up”):

Blueberry Shrub Vodka Martini
Blueberry Shrub Vodka Martini
  • 2 oz. Base Spirit
  • 1/2 oz. Beverage Syrup (Shrub or Simple Syrup)
  • 1/2 oz. Complementary Liqueur
  • Bitters (anywhere from a dash to 5 drops)

For Cocktails that are served over ice (on the rocks or on crushed ice):

  • 2 parts spirit
  • 1 part citrus
  • 1/2 part drink syrup
  • Splash of soda
  • muddled fresh herb, berry or vegetable

For Easy Mocktails:

  • 1 part Beverage Syrup
  • 4 parts Carbonated non-alcoholic beverage (i.e., club soda, ginger Ale, Ginger Beer, tonic water, etc.)
  • muddled herb, berry or vegetable

If you are interested in specific cocktail recipes tested by yours truly and family, enter cocktails in the search bar and you’ll find several posts on specific recipes using shrub syrups.  Some of the recipes use HeathGlen’s beverage syrups or shrub syrups and some are just fun seasonal cocktails to try with or without the syrups.

Spicy Michalada Craft cocktail using beer and Orange Chipotle shrub syrup
Spicy Michalada (Beer with Orange Chipotle Shrub Syrup)

The recipe for the Spicy Michalada is simply as follows:

  1. Rim a beer glass with chipotle powder,
  2. add 1/2 oz Orange Chipotle Shrub Syrup to glass,
  3. Top off with your favorite beer.

Take inspiration from our syrup recipes or our cocktail recipes and create your own drink syrups. If, however, you are not in the “spirit” to make your own syrups, or don’t have the time or ingredients, you can always purchase them online from HeathGlen.

3 Comments

  1. Tomato Shrub Syrup: 3 Drink Recipes on July 26, 2019 at 7:36 am

    […] click here to see methods for making and using shrub syrups. […]

  2. […] For more information on DIY shrub syrups click here. […]

  3. […] It’s that time of the year….cranberries, pumpkin, gløggs, toddies, hot chocolate and of course, champagne.  In keeping with the holiday “spirit”, here are some recipes for craft cocktails and mocktails using a Cranberry Thyme Shrub Syrup and/or a Cranberry Ginger Simple Syrup as the flavor enhancer.  If you want to make your own cranberry shrub syrups for these cocktails, see this post. […]

We'd love to engage with you. Comments are always welcomed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: